Insulated water bottles have become trendy over the last few years, partly thanks to a move toward more eco-friendly hydration options. If you want to invest in a high-quality, durable, insulated water bottle, one that can stand up to hours of activity, you’ve likely come across and narrowed your search down to two brands: Hydroflask and Yeti.
If so, which should be your final choice?
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: The Main Differences
When it comes down to it, both the Hydroflask 18-ounce variant and the Yeti 26-ounce standard option are very fine insulated water bottles. They’ll both do the job and, if you buy one versus the other, and you only use it on occasion, you likely won’t have any complaints.
However, if you use your vacuum insulation water bottle on a very regular basis and during outdoor activities where having a durable water bottle matters, then you want to make the smartest purchase possible. That’s where knowing the key differences between the Hydroflask and the Yeti matters.
So, what are the main differences between Hydroflask and Yeti?
The key differences between the Hydroflask and Yeti insulated water bottles come down to:
- Price (Hydroflask products are generally much cheaper)
- Hardware (Both are BPA free)
Other factors do come into play, such as durability, warranty and cleaning options, but these won’t matter as much in your buying decision as to the above.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Hardware Comparison
In terms of hardware, both water bottle brands use the same type of insulation — a double-wall vacuum insulation design. Basically, the design consists of two walls surrounding your drink, with an empty space between the two walls, which prevents your cold drinks from becoming hot and your hot drinks from becoming cold. Both water bottles do, however, lose temperature whenever you open the cap.
This insulation design keeps drinks at their temperatures or thereabouts for approximately four to six hours.
If you are looking for a wide mouth water bottle, they both make those.
What about the water bottle handle?
The Yeti water bottle lids feature a large handle that most users say can fit three fingers easily.
In comparison, the Hydroflask lid features a much smaller handle that juts out at an awkward angle that many users find uncomfortable. Other Hydroflask lids are available for purchase, but users have to go out of their way to find and buy them.
The Yeti lid is also larger than the Hydroflask lid, at 2.75 inches compared to 2.28 inches. This means most Yeti users can fit both mouth and nose in the bottle when drinking. And if you have a yeti tumbler, the lid is not leakproof, and if it spills in your bag, you will be left with a mess. But the Hydroflask lids are leakproof, so you are safe with that one!
Where the Yeti lid falls short is sanitation. The Yeti lid screws into the bottle, whereas the Hydroflask lid screws onto the bottle. This means the area where you drink is protected from outside germs with a Hydroflask bottle, but you’re touching the exposed bottle rim with your lip when you drink from a Yeti bottle.
As for the grip of each, the bottles differ quite a lot.
Yeti ramblers are made from stainless steel construction, which means a slicker exterior that you might find difficult to grasp when you’re on the go, especially if you’re sweating, wet from swimming, etc.
Hydroflask bottles, however, are coated with a powder coat paint that makes gripping easy.
The winner? It’s a tie.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Durability
If you use your insulated water bottle at the gym or while doing any strenuous outdoor activity, such as hiking, climbing, kayaking or the like, then you want a water bottle with some durability that can stand up to any spills, knocks or bumps. You will also want to make sure your cold water or other cold beverage starts cold.
On the flip side, if you are camping, you will want the double-wall insulation to keep your hot water or hot beverages hot.
Both Hydroflask and Yeti water bottles are fairly durable, but Yeti is often considered the more durable of the two. However, you likely won’t notice the difference unless you’re really giving your water bottle a heavy beating. Even then, the most damage you’ll probably see is some small denting or chipped paint on the Hydroflask bottle.
The winner? Yeti.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Custom Options
If you order your insulated water bottle online, you’ll find an array of custom options. However, Yeti really takes the prize when it comes to customization.
Yeti shoppers can pick from an array of logos, engravings and more (if they’re willing to pay the price) to make their insulated water bottle as unique as the like. You can choose from flip lids, flex caps, wide mouth and even a TripleHaul cap depending on what type of yeti product you are looking to get.
Hydroflask shoppers, however, only have the option to pick through a range of colors, lids and straps.
The winner? Yeti.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Price
If you’re sticking to a budget, then there’s no competition — you’ll want to go with Hydroflask.
Currently, the basic Hydroflask 18-ounce standard mouth insulated bottle is $30. There are 11 colors to choose from.
The Yeti standard, 26-ounce Rambler insulated water bottle with a chug cap (which eliminates that pesky sanitation issue mentioned above), is available in 10 colors and is $45.
The clear winner? Hydroflask.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Cleaning
If you don’t have time to wash your insulated water bottle on a regular basis (which is going to result in a smelly bottle, let’s be honest), then you’ll want to go with the Yeti option, as Yeti insulated water bottles are dishwasher safe.
Hydroflask water bottles are not dishwasher safe and require you to regularly hand wash your bottle.
The winner? Yeti.
Hydroflask vs. Yeti: Warranty
Hydroflask offers a lifetime warranty on its insulated water bottles, while Yeti only offers a five-year warranty.
The winner? Hydroflask.
Which is Better: Hydroflask or Yeti?
It really depends on what you’re looking for and your budget. If you have plenty of cash to spend and want a high-quality product that you can customize to your heart’s content, go with Yeti. However, if you want to save some cash and just need a high-quality, insulated water bottle that’s going to serve you well, and you don’t mind some chipped paint and some hand cleaning every now and then, go with the Hydroflask option.
Either way you go, you can find a variety of options from both Yeti and Hydroflask on Amazon and they are both a huge step up from Nalgene. Plus you are also saving the environment because you aren’t using a plastic water bottle!
You might also be interested in: The 12 Best Exercise Bikes [For All Types Of Cyclists]